| Trading
shots on bullets Coast Guard's live-fire proposal prompts lead
debate
STURGEON BAY -- Carl Scholz worries about thousands of toxic
lead bullets sinking to the bottom of the Great Lakes, an
ecosystem that supports millions of creatures.
Chuck Weier worries about terrorism, someday exploding onto
the shores of his beloved Lake Michigan.
Scholz, of the Northeast Audubon Society, and Weier, president
of the Wisconsin Federation of Great Lakes Sport Fishing Clubs
are at two ends of the Coast Guard live-fire exercise issue.
"We're concerned about the lead," Scholz said Wednesday
at a public hearing at a Sturgeon Bay conference center.
"They never mentioned the effect on plankton. Larval
fish eat plankton. Even though they said its 10 parts per
billion, nonetheless, lead is toxic."
But Weier said many of the 4,000 members of the sport fishing
federation favor live fire exercises, because "we don't
live in the same world we lived in 10 years ago, before 9-11."
The U.S. Coast Guard announced in August that it wanted to
create 34 massive firing ranges for a weapon that can shoot
10 lead bullets a second. It's already conducting live fire
exercises with the last one in September near Superior.
The agency says it must train its Coast Guardsmen to handle
the new, more powerful M240-B machine guns to be ready for
terrorism. However, critics say three tons of lead from spent
bullets plopped into the Great Lakes each year will pollute
drinking water.
Fourteen of the live fire zones would be on Lake Michigan,
including one about 10 miles east of downtown Milwaukee. Zones
would also be located near Kenosha, Manitowoc and Sturgeon
Bay. All of the proposed zones are at least five miles from
shore.
The plan, which was released last summer in the relatively
obscure Federal Register, was quickly placed on hold after
sharp criticism from politicians, environmentalists and boaters.
The agency scheduled several public meetings in states that
border the Great Lakes. It was Wisconsin's turn Wednesday.
Wednesday's session drew about 50 people including anglers,
boaters, environmentalists and others who live and play on
Lake Michigan.
Thomas Dogan, of the Lake Michigan Yachting Association,
pointed out that the Great Lakes represent 90% of America's
fresh water and added that lead-based paint has been illegal
for years and anglers are barred form dropping lead sinkers
in lakes.
Comments in Sturgeon Bay Wednesday hit the same themes as
those in public hearings held throughout the Great Lakes region,
said Robert K. Lanier, Coast Guard assistant public affairs
officer. The Wisconsin hearing was the last of nine public
meetings scheduled by the Coast Guard.
Written comments about live-fire exercises on the Great Lakes
will be accepted by the Coast Guard through Monday. |